SPY Day Trading vs Dodgy's Dungeon: which is worth paying for?
SPY Day Trading ranks #2 on tradingmentorreviews and Dodgy's Dungeon ranks #3, so our data already favours SPY Day Trading. That is a starting point, not an answer — the two differ on price, format and who they suit, and the table below is the honest version of the comparison.
SPY Day Trading
$98.00 / month · #2
- Strong reviews on Eric's mentorship and teaching style
- Focused specifically on SPY options strategy
- Low $98/month price relative to other mentorship groups
Dodgy's Dungeon
$100.00 / month · #3
- Daily live streams most mornings, ICT/IFVG focused
- Reviewers say the strategy has held up over years
- Aims to make traders self-sufficient, not dependent
Side by side
| SPY Day Trading | Dodgy's Dungeon | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $98.00 / month | $100.00 / month |
| Member rating | 5.0 / 5 (19 reviews) | 4.7 / 5 (359 reviews) |
| Members | 798 | 1,435 |
| Rank on this site | #2 of 49 | #3 of 49 |
| Best for | Traders wanting focused SPY options mentorship from one teacher | Traders wanting daily live ICT and IFVG breakdowns |
| Skip it if | You want a detailed strategy breakdown before joining | You need exact, spelled-out entry and exit rules |
| Refunds | Set by seller at checkout | All sales final |
| Selling on Whop for | 2.7 years | 2.5 years |
On price, SPY Day Trading is the cheaper entry at $98.00 / month against $100.00 / month. Cheaper is not better when the thing you are buying is other people's time, but it does lower the cost of being wrong.
Where each one falls short
SPY Day Trading
- Marketing emphasizes large profit potential without guarantees
- Public description is thin on specific strategy details
Dodgy's Dungeon
- No refunds — all sales final
- Several reviewers say entry/exit criteria can be vague
Choose SPY Day Trading if…
Traders wanting focused SPY options mentorship from one teacher. Skip it if you want a detailed strategy breakdown before joining.
Choose Dodgy's Dungeon if…
Traders wanting daily live ICT and IFVG breakdowns. Skip it if you need exact, spelled-out entry and exit rules.
Our take
Dodgy's Dungeon has the stronger evidence base of the two — more verified buyers behind its rating, which matters more than the rating itself. SPY Day Trading is the pick if the format or price suits you better; a slightly lower score is not a reason to buy something that does not fit how you work.
Full detail on both: SPY Day Trading review and Dodgy's Dungeon review. The wider ranking is in our trading courses and mentorships table.
Frequently asked questions
SPY Day Trading or Dodgy's Dungeon — which is better?
On our blended score SPY Day Trading ranks higher, driven by network conversion data, payout volume and review count. But "better" depends on budget and format: read the "choose this one if" sections, because the two suit different buyers.
Can I join both SPY Day Trading and Dodgy's Dungeon?
Yes — they are separate Whop purchases with separate billing, and nothing stops you subscribing to both. Most people are better served picking one, running it for a full billing cycle, and judging it properly before adding a second.
Do you get paid to rank one above the other?
No. Both links are affiliate links and we earn a commission either way, which is exactly why commission rate is excluded from the score. A seller paying 15% can and does outrank one paying 80%.
